Government releases policy statement on new points-based immigration system
20 February 2020
The Government has announced it will deliver a points-based immigration system, both for sponsored and unsponsored work. At least initially, the proposed system will modify existing arrangements rather than being a radical overhaul.
The policy statement, published on 19 February, has been released ahead of a more detailed white paper expected in March.
The Government has recognised that a complete transformation of the border and immigration system will be a major undertaking, so we can expect the changes from 1 January 2021 to be followed by a ‘wider multi-year programme of change’.
The only unheralded proposal in the policy document is a new proposal to introduce a capped, unsponsored points-based route in addition to the Global Talent route. This will be rolled-out later than the beginning of 2021, and the Government intends to engage with stakeholders over the next year regarding what the route will look like. The implication is that it would be similar to the old Highly Skilled Migrant Program/Tier 1 General.
In a move that will no doubt frustrate civil servants at the Home Office, points-criteria will be added to the Global Talent route, which has just replaced Tier 1 Exceptional Talent and now sits outside the points-based system. This could bring welcome objectivity and predictability to the route however.
The policy statement is completely silent on what reforms are planned to sponsorship arrangements, noting only that improvements will come after 1 January 2021. Employers will need to review how many EEA/Swiss skilled workers their business is likely to recruit from 2021. Employers who have not needed a sponsor licence in the past should consider applying for one soon. Existing sponsors should consider increasing their CoS allocations and applying for additional licence tiers if necessary.
Sponsored skilled workers
In terms of reforms to what is currently Tier 2, the Government has accepted all of the MAC’s recommendations below:
- Reducing the minimum skills threshold from RQF level 6 (equivalent to degree level) to RQF level 3 (equivalent to A-level)
- Reducing the general salary threshold from £30,000 to £25,600 and retaining occupation-specific thresholds – migrants will still need to meet whichever is the higher threshold in order to qualify
- Ignoring allowances and pension contributions in the calculation of salary
- Using national pay scales for certain occupations in the NHS and schools instead of the general and occupation-specific salary thresholds
- Setting the occupation-specific salary threshold for new entrants at 70% of those for experienced workers
- Removing the resident labour market test
- Not introducing regional salary thresholds or other arrangements
The Government has chosen however to depart from the MAC’s recommendations by proposing that additional points elements are included in the skilled worker route, rather than moving away from applying points-related criteria to it.
The Government sees the shortage occupation list as a means of providing tradeable points that make up for having a salary between £20,480 and £25,999. it will commission the Migration Advisory Committee to produce a new shortage occupation list and to keep this under review.
The existing points test will be revised so that a minimum of 70 points is required as follows:
|Offer of job by approved sponsor||No||20|
|Job at appropriate skill level||No||20|
|Speaks English at required level||No||10|
|Salary of £20,480 (minimum) – £23,039||Yes||0|
|Salary of £23,040 – £25,599||Yes||10|
|Salary of £25,600 or above||Yes||20|
|Job in a shortage occupation (as designated by the MAC)||Yes||20|
|Education qualification: PhD in subject relevant to the job||Yes||10|
|Education qualification: PhD in a STEM subject relevant to the job||Yes||20|
Source: Home Office
Despite announcing that lower skills will be eligible for sponsorship, the new points-test will mean that some new entrants and public sector workers earning less than £25,600 will be ineligible to qualify unless they are also able to gain at least 20 tradeable points. That could be done if they are eligible for 20 points by having a PhD in a STEM subject that is relevant to the job offer, or the job offer is in a shortage occupation. Alternatively they could score ten points by earning at least £23,040 and an additional ten points through having a PhD relevant to the job on offer. Given the MAC’s recommendation that Tier 2 be opened up to assist with the medium-skilled labour shortages that turning off free movement from the EEA will cause, this points structure appears to scupper this intended aim. The Government has however stated that further guidance on points tables and other details will be released at a later date, so the table above may not be an accurate representation of what the final arrangements will be.
The statement also provides no detail on intra-company transfer arrangements, aside from stating (in a footnote) that the new system will comply with commitments for intra-company transferees in line with existing and future trade agreements.
The Government’s aim is for overall migration to be reduced following the end of free movement, stating that to staff lower-skilled roles, employers will need to look towards ‘investment in staff retention, productivity and wider investment in technology and innovation’ as well as the pool of workers who apply under the EU Settlement Scheme, youth mobility participants and the dependants of skilled migrants.
An exception has been recognised for the agricultural sector, with the seasonal workers pilot being expanded from 2,500 to 10,000 places.
However, it is very likely that the Home Office will be lobbied by representatives of the sectors hardest hit by this policy, including the hospitality and social care industries. It is also possible that some occupations lower than RQF level 3 may be allowed under the route for sponsored skilled workers on an exceptional basis if severe labour shortages emerge for particular occupations.
We will be covering the new system in more detail at our next half-day Immigration Law Academy on 24 March 2020.
If you have any queries regarding this announcement, please contact a member of the immigration team.
Today’s workforce is increasingly international, with companies competing for talent on a global scale.
Employment is a central focus of our business, with over 170 lawyers in our team supporting our clients in managing their people.