Back
Finding your forum: a data-driven guide to SEP litigation strategy

Country by country
Global FRAND/RAND rates
Since Unwired Planet, the English courts can determine the terms of a global FRAND/RAND licence without both parties’ consent, provided the court finds at least one UK SEP valid, essential, and infringed. Subsequent Court of Appeal authority (Nokia v OPPO and Tesla v InterDigital) confirms this jurisdiction persists even where UK sales make up a tiny fraction of the portfolio’s global footprint. The court is not, however, a “global FRAND policeman” and cannot restrain other courts from also asserting rate-setting jurisdiction.
Interim licences pending final decision
The UK pioneered court-declared “interim licences” to hold the ring pending a final FRAND/RAND trial; this began with Panasonic v Xiaomi. The court’s task is deliberately narrow: it must decide whether the SEP holder is owed an interim licence, and if so on what (usually mid-point) terms, which the court can adjust once it settles the final licence.
Speed
The Patents Court aims to reach trial within 12 months of commencement, but in practice it usually takes 12–18 months and few cases meet the 12-month target. The Patents Court frequently expedites FRAND/RAND trials ahead of validity/infringement proceedings, as in Panasonic v Xiaomi & Oppo and Lenovo v InterDigital. Interim licence application hearings last 1-2 days and a decision is usually released within 1 month: Panasonic v Xiaomi and Lenovo v Ericsson. This reflects a deliberate policy: UK courts are concerned that delay lets SEP holders use foreign injunctions as leverage while a UK trial is pending. Overall, the UK is best described as medium-fast speed: faster than the average US or Indian timelines, but marginally slower than Germany or the UPC because of full evidential trials on both infringement and validity together.
Cost
UK patent litigation is expensive by international standards. Patents Court costs commonly range from around £1 million up to several million pounds. UK FRAND/RAND trials are resource-intensive, typically running many weeks with extensive expert economic evidence. Costs remain high relative to civil-law jurisdictions because of the adversarial procedure, extensive expert reports, and the “loser pays” regime — broadly comparable to complex, multi-week Commercial Court trials generally. The “loser pays” principle means a successful party can typically recover 70–90% of costs in the Patents Court, which somewhat tempers the net exposure but does not remove the high headline spend. FRAND/RAND litigation tends to cost more than an equivalent ordinary commercial claim, however, because the same parties are typically also funding parallel proceedings over the same portfolio in several other countries simultaneously.
Disclosure/discovery
The Patents Court permits fairly extensive disclosure for high-value disputes. Disclosure in FRAND trials centres on production of comparable licences, which is often extensive and contentious. This places the UK toward the more invasive end of the spectrum compared with civil law systems, though still narrower than US-style discovery. FRAND/RAND disclosure is often narrower in scope but more commercially sensitive, since comparable licences are documents competitors would not otherwise have to exchange, which is why bespoke, multi-tier confidentiality clubs have become routine.
Transparency and precedent value
The UK is consistently ranked among the top jurisdictions globally for enforcement quality, judicial specialisation and the consistency and influence of decisions, which reinforces its precedential value both domestically and as a reference point for other common law courts. UK FRAND/RAND judgments are fully public (courts redact only true commercial secrets) and unusually detailed, extending to methodology (top-down cross-checks, comparable licences, willing-licensor/licensee analysis). They carry strong precedential weight domestically and are frequently cited by foreign courts, including the Chinese Supreme People’s Court in Sharp v Oppo. This reflects the open justice principle underlying all English commercial litigation, but FRAND/RAND cases push it further: courts have disclosed granular technical and commercial detail (such as component-level chip design information) beyond the confidentiality protections typical of general commercial claims, and beyond the “attorneys’ eyes only” practice standard in comparable US litigation.
Evidence Assessment/Cross-examination
A single specialist Patents Court judge (not a jury) tries FRAND/RAND trials following full disclosure, expert reports, and extensive cross-examination of economists and industry witnesses on royalty methodology and comparable licences. This produces detailed findings capable of surviving rigorous appellate scrutiny, as the multiple Court of Appeal and Supreme Court judgments upholding first-instance determinations show. What distinguishes FRAND trials is mainly scale and technical complexity, not the underlying evidentiary technique.
Global FRAND/RAND rates
US courts have set global RAND rates, as in Microsoft v Motorola, but historically only where the parties themselves invoked the court’s jurisdiction to do so, rather than as an inherent incident of a single US patent finding.
Interim licences pending final decision
The US has no doctrine of a court-ordered interim licence. Disputes are instead managed through parallel infringement suits, ITC Section 337 exclusion-order proceedings, and increasingly anti-suit injunctions against foreign proceedings. The ITC does not determine FRAND/RAND terms; it considers only whether FRAND-related public-interest factors should deny exclusionary relief, assessed by whether the SEP holder’s conduct was manifestly contrary to good faith. The Ericsson v Lenovo Federal Circuit ruling armed US courts with a broadened anti-suit-injunction power as the practical alternative to an interim licence.
Speed
US patent litigation is comparatively slow, averaging three to five years from complaint to the end of appeal, with average time to trial nationally around 29–32 months even in busy jurisdictions such as California. Some “rocket docket” districts can bring cases to trial in under two years, and forum selection is a deliberate strategy for parties wanting speed. US FRAND-adjacent litigation can move quickly in patentee-friendly districts (Eastern/Western Texas, Central District of California), with jury trials and retrials sometimes concluding within a year or two of filing. ITC investigations are statutorily fast, targeting 16–18 months to adjudication. District court FRAND-rate litigation proper is often slower and is frequently overtaken by settlement once a jury verdict or ITC exclusion order creates leverage. This broadly tracks ordinary US federal commercial litigation (typically 18 months to 3 years to trial); the ITC’s compressed timetable is genuinely exceptional, which is why FRAND-adjacent disputes are so often routed there to generate leverage faster than district court litigation allows.
Cost
US litigation costs are the highest of any FRAND/RAND forum, driven by extensive party-controlled discovery, e-discovery, depositions, and multiple testifying experts — features inherent to US commercial litigation generally rather than unique to FRAND/RAND disputes. Roughly half of costs are incurred by the close of discovery, driven by extensive e-discovery, depositions and expert fees. What pushes FRAND-adjacent costs higher is the combination of parallel district court, ITC and foreign proceedings running concurrently over the same portfolio, layered on top of the already discovery-heavy US baseline.
Disclosure/discovery
US discovery is by far the broadest and most invasive of any jurisdiction surveyed, encompassing document production, interrogatories, requests for admission and extensive depositions of both fact and expert witnesses. This scope reflects the ordinary Federal Rules of Civil Procedure rather than anything FRAND-specific, though FRAND/RAND cases generate an unusually large discovery footprint given the volume of licensing negotiation histories, sales data and comparable-licence portfolios involved.
Transparency and precedent value
US patent decisions are transparent and precedent-rich. District court opinions, jury verdicts and, critically, Federal Circuit appellate decisions are all publicly available and form a dense, binding body of patent law that is closely tracked internationally. The Federal Circuit's exclusive appellate jurisdiction over patent cases produces a relatively unified body of precedent despite disparate district court practices, and its rulings (for example on claim construction and damages) are highly influential globally. This transparency is standard for all US federal civil litigation; what is comparatively unusual in FRAND/RAND cases is the volume of confidential licensing information parties seek to protect through sealed filings, often producing more heavily redacted public records than a typical commercial dispute.
Evidence Assessment/Cross-examination
The US system provides for thorough evidentiary testing, particularly where a jury trial is available. Depositions before trial already involve extensive cross-examination-style questioning, and at trial witnesses undergo direct and cross-examination before a lay jury, requiring evidence to be presented persuasively as well as substantively. Expert witnesses on infringement, invalidity and damages are central and heavily contested, often with competing experts from both sides subject to searching cross-examination. This adversarial, jury-oriented model makes US evidentiary practice among the most exhaustive in the world, albeit at high cost and over a long timeframe.
Global FRAND/RAND rates
German courts do not generally set global FRAND/RAND rates; they instead assess whether a SEP holder’s offer (whatever its scope) is FRAND/RAND under the Huawei v ZTE negotiation framework, and have been willing to find implementers unwilling licensees and grant injunctions rather than adjudicate a global rate. In Access Advance v Vestel, the Düsseldorf court declined to set a global rate for the HEVC pool. Munich’s 7th Civil Chamber instead focuses on comparable-licence benchmarking, rejecting “top-down” patent counting as the primary methodology — a more conservative, patentee-protective approach than the English top-down cross-check.
Interim licences pending final decision
Germany does not recognise the English concept of a court-ordered interim licence and has actively resisted its export: the Mannheim Local Division of the UPC and the Munich I Regional Court granted InterDigital ex parte “anti-interim-licence injunctions” against Amazon, holding that a compulsory interim licence “fundamentally undermines a patent holder’s enforcement rights” by removing the injunction as a negotiating lever. These orders, backed by daily fines for non-compliance, were the first of their kind worldwide.
Speed
Germany is one of the fastest major patent litigation venues due to its bifurcated system, in which infringement is decided separately from, and typically well before, validity. Infringement judgments are commonly delivered within 10–18 months, with some venues issuing decisions in as little as six months. German FRAND/RAND proceedings are comparatively fast with courts aiming to decide within nine to ten months of a FRAND/RAND hearing, and anti-interim-licence and anti-suit applications adjudicated within days on a without-notice basis.
Cost
Litigation costs are comparatively moderate, since German civil procedure lacks US-style discovery and depositions and relies on documentary submissions and limited witness examination — a general feature of German commercial litigation, not something FRAND-specific. The distinctive FRAND/RAND cost driver is instead the multiplication effect of patent-by-patent enforcement across a large portfolio: because SEP holders pursue patents in separate proceedings, implementers can face cumulative cost and injunction risk across many parallel cases, with the Munich guidance calculating enforcement security that can run into six figures per case. Germany is consistently ranked among the most cost-effective European jurisdictions, well ahead of the UK, due to the absence of extensive discovery and jury trials and statutory caps on recoverable attorneys' fees tied to the value in dispute. The losing party reimburses court fees, expenses and statutory-rate attorneys' fees.
Disclosure/discovery
Germany has no US-style pre-trial discovery or UK-style disclosure obligation; each party must independently gather and present its own evidence. This makes German disclosure among the least invasive of the jurisdictions. German procedure has no general pre-trial discovery; courts instead compel production of specific documents, particularly comparable licences, by targeted order — a general feature of German civil procedure, not a FRAND-specific limitation. What is FRAND-specific is the Munich guidance’s requirement that implementers make “prompt disclosure of quantities relevant to the standard” to demonstrate genuine willingness to license, with courts assessing whether comparable licences were properly disclosed and unpacked to justify a proposed rate.
Transparency and precedent value
German patent judgments are reasoned and give rise to a well-developed, influential body of case law, particularly from the specialist Düsseldorf, Mannheim and Munich regional courts, whose jurisprudence is followed nationally for its reliability. German judges rarely reveal the broader concepts shaping their approach, and written decisions typically focus narrowly on facts and arguments — characteristic of German civil judgments generally. Decisions are not formally binding precedent, but practitioners closely track influential regional and appellate guidance (Munich, Mannheim, Düsseldorf) as de facto guidance. General Ggeneral access to court files is more restricted than in the UK or US: civil court records are not automatically open to the public, and inspection requires demonstrating a specific legal interest.
Evidence Assessment/Cross-examination
German civil procedure is judge-led rather than adversarial; there is no jury, and judges actively direct the taking of evidence, which is limited to five recognised methods: visual inspection, witness and party hearings, expert opinions and production of documents. German civil procedure emphasises written pleadings and documentary evidence with more limited oral cross-examination than in common-law systems, generally placing less weight on live testimony — not a feature unique to FRAND/RAND cases. Courts assess FRAND/RAND principles under Huawei v ZTE largely through correspondence and comparable-licence unpacking; where oral hearings occur, they test party submissions efficiently rather than through the extended cross-examination typical of the UK or US. Compared with UK or US cross-examination-driven trials, evidentiary testing in Germany is more inquisitorial and less confrontational, though still rigorous within its own framework.
Global FRAND/RAND rates
The UPC courts do not generally set global FRAND/RAND rates; and instead assesses whether an implementers offer is FRAND/RAND compliant under the Huawei v ZTE negotiation framework.
Interim licences pending final decision
The UPC has been the most forceful opponent of the English interim-licence doctrine, with its Mannheim Local Division granting the world’s first “anti-interim-licence injunction” against Amazon, characterising the English mechanism as a “de facto prohibition on litigation” that coerces patent holders into abandoning legal rights elsewhere, and framing its own order as “exclusively defensive”.
Speed
Strict, largely non-extendable deadlines for statements of claim and defence front-load the litigation and make the UPC one of the fastest patent courts in the world. The UPC prioritizes speed: its Rules of Procedure target a final oral hearing within one year (a roughly nine-month written phase, a three-month interim phase, a one-day hearing, and judgment within six weeks), and urgent applications — such as the anti-interim-licence and anti-suit orders against Amazon — have been decided within days on a without-notice basis. This one-year target applies to all UPC litigation, not only FRAND/RAND disputes, and was deliberately designed to beat the two-to-three-year timelines typical of comparable multi-party commercial claims before national courts in its contracting states.
Cost
The UPC reduces costs relative to litigating the same European patent separately in multiple national courts, since a single unitary judgment covers all contracting states and avoids duplicated proceedings; its tight timetable also limits costly interlocutory skirmishing, though multinational panels and translation requirements add overhead. UPC costs are lower than UK or US litigation but not negligible. This consolidation benefit applies to any UPC patent dispute, not just FRAND/RAND cases, and is a genuine structural improvement over the pre-UPC position of funding parallel national litigation in each contracting state.
Disclosure/discovery
The UPC provides only limited, targeted evidence-gathering rather than discovery. There is limited ongoing discovery process once proceedings begin, and the court is reluctant to admit new evidence after the statement of claim. This front-loaded, restrictive approach requires parties to prepare comprehensive evidence before filing. The UPC has a comparatively narrow evidence-production regime: Article 59 UPCA and Rule 190 RoP allow the court to order production of evidence (including comparable licences) subject to confidentiality protection, and Rule 196 allows evidence-preservation orders including seizure of goods. This targeted, continental-style approach applies to all UPC litigation; comparable-licence production orders and confidentiality clubs are simply its FRAND-specific application.
Transparency and precedent value
Precedent is actively developing but transparency remains a work in progress. UPC decisions and orders are published on the court's website, and the Court of Appeal has begun setting out general principles, including on third-party access to pleadings and evidence. The UPC publishes decisions (with redactions for confidential FRAND/RAND terms) and works to ensure consistent interpretation across local divisions and the Court of Appeal. Redaction of FRAND/RAND terms is the only respect in which FRAND/RAND transparency differs from the UPC’s general practice.
Evidence Assessment/Cross-examination
The UPC’s interim procedure lets the judge-rapporteur order further pleadings, expert evidence, experiments, inspections and witness hearings, with the scope of questioning defined in advance. The emphasis on speed means the oral hearing on infringement and validity, including any witness examination, is typically compressed into a single day, with the great weight of the case built on the front-loaded written pleadings and documentary evidence rather than extended live testimony. This makes UPC evidentiary practice efficient but less exhaustive than UK or US cross-examination.
Global FRAND/RAND rates
Chinese courts have positioned themselves as assertive global rate-setters. In 2021, the Supreme People’s Court of the People’s Republic of China affirmed the jurisdictional ruling of the Shenzhen Intermediate People’s Court in Sharp v. OPPO holding that it is appropriate for Chinese courts to rule on global licensing terms for SEPs. And, in 2023, the Chongqing Court in Nokia v. Oppo established the first global licensing rates for SEPs, including a global aggregate rate for 4G and 5G smartphones.
Interim licences pending final decision
China has no equivalent to the UK’s interim-licence doctrine. Instead, Chinese courts have relied heavily on anti-suit injunctions to protect their own rate-setting jurisdiction, issuing anti-suit injunctions in Xiaomi v InterDigital (Wuhan Intermediate People’s Court), Oppo v Sharp (Shenzen Intermediate People’s Court), Samsung v Ericsson, (Wuhan Intermediate People’s Court) and ZTE v Conversant (Shenzen Intermediate People’s Court). However, ongoing WTO concerns over the practice may temper China’s willingness to grant further ASIs.
Speed
China is a fast patent litigation forum - patent infringement cases in the specialised IP courts typically conclude within twelve to eighteen months. Appeals to the Supreme People’s Court average around six to twelve months. It is jurisdictional skirmishing distinctive to multi-jurisdictional FRAND/RAND disputes, not the underlying Chinese court process, that accounts for most delays in China.
Cost
Costs are generally lower than in the US or UK because Chinese civil procedure lacks common-law-style discovery and depositions, relying on documentary evidence, expert opinions and comparable-licence analysis — a general feature of Chinese civil procedure, not FRAND-specific. The losing party bears litigation costs, and courts can include reasonable attorneys' fees within a damages award, though overall damages (and hence the value that drives cost scaling) remain lower than in the US or Germany.
Disclosure/discovery
There is no formal discovery or disclosure procedure in China. The burden of proof generally lies with the party asserting a claim, though it can shift to the defendant in specific circumstances. Litigants instead rely on evidence preservation orders, notarisation, court investigation and document submission orders, and courts frequently appoint independent technical investigators to assist with complex technical evidence. This is considerably less invasive than UK or US discovery, closer to the German and Brazilian models. Chinese courts obtain comparable licences primarily through party submission and unpacking of existing agreements (as in Oppo v Nokia), rather than compelled disclosure — a general feature of Chinese civil procedure, not a FRAND-specific limitation. Courts heavily redact confidential data in published judgments, and where particularly sensitive information needs protection, access can be restricted to attorneys’ eyes only, or even to the judges alone — a more restrictive tool than is typically available elsewhere.
Transparency and precedent value
Lack of transparency is a feature of Chinese SEP litigation: China has no open-access system, increasingly publishes judgments anonymised, and did not make the landmark Oppo v Nokia judgment available on the official database over a year after the ruling — prompting the Delhi High Court and the European Union to formally request access to the unredacted text. Prior decisions are persuasive rather than binding, though Supreme People’s Court rulings carry strong guiding authority. This reflects a broader trend across Chinese commercial litigation, contrasting sharply with the open-justice default in the UK, US and India; the international pressure in Oppo v Nokia shows FRAND disputes attract unusually intense scrutiny of this general gap.
Evidence Assessment/Cross-examination
Chinese courts favour a documentary, judge-led approach over adversarial cross-examination. Judges actively investigate evidence during preliminary hearings, and technical investigation officers may be appointed to support the panel on complex technical points. There is no jury, and cases are heard by panels of three or five judges, sometimes including lay jurors, with an emphasis on well-organised, comprehensive documentary evidence packages rather than extended oral testing of witnesses. Chinese SEP hearings are judge-led rather than adversarial, with the court weighing comparable-licence evidence, patent-counting methodology and top-down analysis, and expressly considering negotiation conduct (including hold-out) in setting the rate, as in the Supreme People’s Court’s ACT v Oppo ruling. There is less emphasis on live cross-examination than in the UK or US; the court instead scrutinises documentary and expert-report evidence directly — a general feature of China’s inquisitorial civil-law tradition, applied here to FRAND’s/RAND’s specific economic and technical content.
Global FRAND/RAND rates
India has not yet definitively set a global FRAND/RAND rate, but Delhi High Court commentary and industry reporting describe India as ready to set global FRAND licences once it meets the relevant conditions, reflecting a developing but still cautious posture. Commentators describe the Ericsson v Lava judgment as a landmark that “solidifies India’s position in global SEP disputes,” emphasising global licensing practice, claim mapping and rejection of exhaustion defences, and signalling growing assertiveness without yet delivering a full global rate determination.
Interim licences pending final decision
India has developed a distinct practice of court-supervised interim royalty payments during negotiation, rather than a formal “interim licence” declaration. In Ericsson v Micromax, the Delhi High Court permitted Micromax to pay interim royalties at rates Ericsson initially proposed (e.g., 1.25%–2.00% of net device price by standard) pending negotiation of final FRAND/RAND terms.
Speed
Indian SEP litigation has traditionally been slower than the UK or Germany, reflecting general civil-court backlog, though the Delhi High Court has developed specialist patent-handling practice over the past decade. Interim applications, by contrast, are often heard within a few months, giving litigants relatively quick interim relief even while the substantive trial remains pending for years. Newer specialised IP Divisions at the Delhi, Madras and Calcutta High Courts, with dedicated case management and technical assistance, aim to reduce this backlog, but pendency remains a defining feature of the system
Cost
Litigation costs in India are generally moderate relative to the UK and US, reflecting India’s civil procedure (for example, the absence of extensive US-style discovery, and a lack of jury trials) and lower relative cost of legal services — a general feature of Indian commercial litigation, not FRAND-specific. The additional cost driver in FRAND cases is the need to import substantial international expert evidence on comparable licensing and royalty-base methodology, which a typical domestic dispute would not require.
Disclosure/discovery
India permits discovery through interrogatories and document production orders, but only with the court's leave and subject to relevance objections. The Delhi High Court has shown willingness to compel disclosure of comparable licences. This targeted disclosure is consistent with India’s general common-law approach (as in the UK) and reflects the importance of comparable-licence evidence to non-discrimination. This makes Indian disclosure more invasive than Germany, China or Brazil, but narrower and more discretionary than UK or US practice.
Transparency and precedent value
Indian patent judgments, particularly from the Delhi High Court, are reasoned, published and increasingly precedent-setting. Delhi High Court FRAND/RAND judgments are public and increasingly detailed, with Ericsson v Lava cited as setting an important precedent for future SEP cases.
Evidence Assessment/Cross-examination
India follows a common-law adversarial model with pleadings, disclosure and cross-examination, comparable to the UK, though case duration and formality can extend the evidentiary phase considerably. The Delhi High Court’s willingness to compel comparable-licence production and engage with detailed royalty-base evidence reflects a thorough, if still-maturing, process — the FRAND-specific gap being the courts’ still-developing experience with technical and economic complexity at the depth seen in UK or US case law.
Global FRAND/RAND rates
Arbitration is well-suited to global rate-setting because territoriality constraints that confine national courts do not bind arbitral tribunals, allowing a single tribunal to assess an entire multi-jurisdictional SEP portfolio in one proceeding, which can be time- and cost-effective compared with fighting each patent family separately. The English Court of Appeal’s 2026 decision in Acer v Nokia held that Nokia’s offer of an interim licence adjustable by subsequent ICC arbitration was itself a FRAND-compliant offer, permanently staying the English rate-setting claims in favour of arbitration.
Interim licences pending final decision
Parties can package arbitration itself as (or alongside) an interim-licence mechanism, as in Nokia’s “Adjustable License” proposal, under which interim terms apply until a final ICC award issues. The Court of Appeal’s endorsement of this structure marks a “significant development,” effectively allowing SEP holders to route implementers away from court-declared interim licences and into an arbitration-supervised interim/final structure instead.
Speed
IP arbitration is generally faster than court litigation but slower than expedited alternatives such as mediation. Proponents market arbitration as faster than multi-jurisdictional litigation because it consolidates disputes into one proceeding, though this depends on tribunal constitution and institutional efficiency; critics note arbitration is not categorically faster in every case. This general speed advantage is not FRAND-specific, but complex multi-phase FRAND/RAND arbitrations can undermine it in practice — a proposed two-phase structure requiring two separately constituted tribunals was expected to introduce significant delay before arbitration could even begin.
Cost
Arbitration is generally regarded as more cost-effective than parallel multi-jurisdictional litigation, since parties avoid duplicating evidence and expert reports and can design one tailored procedure. Institutional and tribunal fees are a real expense but are typically offset by consolidation savings — the standard rationale for commercial arbitration generally. In the FRAND/RAND context, the saving can be unusually large, given the realistic alternative may be a dozen or more simultaneous national actions across the SEP holder’s full portfolio.
Disclosure/discovery
Disclosure in FRAND arbitration is flexible and party-designed: tribunals can tailor disclosure of comparable licences and design sampling methodologies for large portfolios — a general feature of commercial arbitration, not FRAND-specific. Tribunals retain full discretion to control the scope and are encouraged to avoid overly broad requests to control time and costs. International arbitration also typically restricts sensitive disclosure to an external-eyes-only basis through to the final hearing, a stricter default than in national court litigation.
Transparency and precedent value
Transparency is arbitration’s principal weakness: awards are typically confidential and non-binding on third parties, creating no public precedent — a general, well-recognised trade-off of arbitration in any field. The Acer v Nokia Court of Appeal noted that ICC arbitration does not automatically impose confidentiality and endorsed publishing awards (with redactions), welcoming Nokia’s proposal for a public non-confidential summary. Awards are generally final with no merits appeal. This trade-off is more consequential in FRAND/RAND cases than most, because the non-discrimination principle depends on market-wide comparable-licence transparency.
Evidence Assessment/Cross-examination
Under the IBA Rules, which most institutional tribunals apply or take cues from, both fact and expert witnesses give written direct testimony and are subject to live cross-examination, though parties commonly waive cross-examination for less contentious witnesses. Tribunals can also appoint independent experts. Overall, evidentiary testing in arbitration is thorough but more flexible and tribunal-controlled than court cross-examination, calibrated case-by-case rather than following fixed procedural rules. Parties can tailor arbitral procedure to the dispute’s complexity, selecting arbitrators with specific FRAND/RAND expertise and designing evidentiary hearings accordingly — a standard advantage of arbitration in any technically complex dispute. Because confidentiality limits how much comparable-licence evidence and reasoning become public, external scrutiny of the tribunal’s rigour is inherently more limited than in a published judgment — a general limitation felt more keenly in FRAND cases given market participants’ direct interest in that evidence.
Global FRAND/RAND rates
No party has ever asked Brazilian courts to set, and Brazilian courts have never set, a global FRAND/RAND rate or declared whether an offer is FRAND/RAND; Brazilian SEP suits instead seek the ordinary local remedies of preliminary and permanent injunctions and damages for the Brazilian territory only. FRAND/RAND analysis is beginning to enter Brazilian jurisprudence as a substantive defence, for example in a São Paulo judge’s bifurcated approach in a case against Nokia, which first examines the FRAND/RAND negotiation history using comparable licences before reaching patent merits.
Interim licences pending final decision
Brazil has no interim-licence concept; instead, its distinctive tool is the statutory preliminary injunction, available as of right to any patent holder including SEP holders regardless of patent type, which can issue ex parte within 24 hours of filing. In Ericsson v Apple, the Rio de Janeiro Court of Appeals partially granted a PI requiring Apple to pay the prior global licence rate or cease using Ericsson’s 5G patents in Brazil, which the Superior Court of Justice later modified to a per-device figure, illustrating how Brazilian PIs function as a de facto interim-payment mechanism.
Speed
Brazilian patent litigation was historically perceived as slow and procedurally rigid, but has become markedly quicker in certain courts, particularly for preliminary relief. PIs are obtainable shortly after filing. Full trials are rare because the PI itself operates as the practical settlement trigger. Full civil trials on the merits, by contrast, can take considerably longer, which is why the PI route, rather than a full trial, has become the dominant venue for both ordinary Brazilian disputes and SEP enforcement alike.
Cost
Brazilian litigation costs are low to moderate. Court fees are generally modest because Brazil lacks formal US-style discovery, and the central fact-finding mechanism is a single court-appointed technical expert whose report is highly persuasive (the party against whom that expert’s report falls prevails less than ten percent of the time) — a general feature of Brazilian civil procedure for any technical dispute. In practice, a SEP litigant’s budget is concentrated almost entirely on influencing that single expert’s report, rather than the competing expert battles typical of a UK or US commercial case. The losing party reimburses court fees, expert fees and witness expenses, and the court separately awards statutory attorneys' fees to the winning lawyer, though contractual attorney fees themselves are generally not recoverable.
Disclosure/discovery
Brazil has no formal, US-style discovery; the process is narrower, more formalised and overseen directly by the court, with parties bearing primary responsibility for producing their own supporting evidence. A party seeking evidence from the other side or a third party must specifically identify the document sought, explain its relevance and justify the belief that it exists and is held by that party, and the judge then decides whether production is required. Within the proceeding, the court-appointed expert conducts the primary fact-finding exercise, producing a persuasive (though not binding) report that heavily influences the final outcome.
Transparency and precedent value
Brazilian judgments are reasoned and increasingly cited in a growing body of SEP case law, with appellate panels of typically three judges able to reassess both legal and factual issues, including the trial court's evaluation of technical evidence. Decisions of Brazilian courts are not binding, and Brazil is a civil-law jurisdiction without stare decisis, so courts decide SEP cases case-by-case with limited precedential value — a general feature of Brazilian commercial law, not FRAND-specific. Nonetheless, a body of consistent, publicly available rulings has developed a broadly “plaintiff-friendly” reputation for Brazilian SEP venues, with tentative signs that courts are beginning to treat FRAND/RAND compliance as decisive to both interim and merits outcomes.
Evidence Assessment/Cross-examination
The Brazilian judge acts as director of an essentially inquisitorial process and is the primary recipient of evidence, which may be documentary, oral or technical, with oral testimony taken personally by the judge at a dedicated hearing. There is no jury and no US- or UK-style adversarial cross-examination of lay witnesses; evidentiary weight instead turns heavily on the credibility and rigour of the court-appointed expert. Because Brazilian judges often lack technical backgrounds, the court-appointed expert is the de facto fact-finder, substituting for the adversarial cross-examination of competing experts used in common-law systems — a general approach Brazilian courts take to any technically complex dispute. This produces a fast, single-expert-driven process rather than an extended trial with live cross-examination, though the growing sophistication of Brazilian FRAND/RAND defences (comparable-licence disclosure, non-discrimination scrutiny) suggests FRAND/RAND litigation is beginning to push evidentiary practice further than a typical Brazilian commercial dispute would require.







