arrow_back

Back

Finding your forum: a data-driven guide to SEP litigation strategy

16 November 2026
schedule

1 min read

Add as a preferred source on GoogleAdd as a preferred source on Google
Choosing the right forum for SEP litigation can make or break your strategy.

Our interactive Forum Selection Tool scores eight leading jurisdictions across the factors that matter most – from speed and cost to disclosure, transparency, and evidential rigour – so you can compare your options at a glance and build a forum strategy grounded in data, not guesswork.

Country by country

Global FRAND/RAND rates

Since Unwired Planet, the English courts can determine the terms of a global FRAND/RAND licence without both parties’ consent, provided the court finds at least one UK SEP valid, essential, and infringed. Subsequent Court of Appeal authority (Nokia v OPPO and Tesla v InterDigital) confirms this jurisdiction persists even where UK sales make up a tiny fraction of the portfolio’s global footprint. The court is not, however, a “global FRAND policeman” and cannot restrain other courts from also asserting rate-setting jurisdiction.
Interim licences pending final decision

The UK pioneered court-declared “interim licences” to hold the ring pending a final FRAND/RAND trial; this began with Panasonic v Xiaomi. The court’s task is deliberately narrow: it must decide whether the SEP holder is owed an interim licence, and if so on what (usually mid-point) terms, which the court can adjust once it settles the final licence.

Speed

The Patents Court aims to reach trial within 12 months of commencement, but in practice it usually takes 12–18 months and few cases meet the 12-month target. The Patents Court frequently expedites FRAND/RAND trials ahead of validity/infringement proceedings, as in Panasonic v Xiaomi & Oppo and Lenovo v InterDigital. Interim licence application hearings last 1-2 days and a decision is usually released within 1 month: Panasonic v Xiaomi and Lenovo v Ericsson. This reflects a deliberate policy: UK courts are concerned that delay lets SEP holders use foreign injunctions as leverage while a UK trial is pending. Overall, the UK is best described as medium-fast speed: faster than the average US or Indian timelines, but marginally slower than Germany or the UPC because of full evidential trials on both infringement and validity together.

Cost

UK patent litigation is expensive by international standards. Patents Court costs commonly range from around £1 million up to several million pounds. UK FRAND/RAND trials are resource-intensive, typically running many weeks with extensive expert economic evidence. Costs remain high relative to civil-law jurisdictions because of the adversarial procedure, extensive expert reports, and the “loser pays” regime — broadly comparable to complex, multi-week Commercial Court trials generally. The “loser pays” principle means a successful party can typically recover 70–90% of costs in the Patents Court, which somewhat tempers the net exposure but does not remove the high headline spend. FRAND/RAND litigation tends to cost more than an equivalent ordinary commercial claim, however, because the same parties are typically also funding parallel proceedings over the same portfolio in several other countries simultaneously.

Disclosure/discovery

The Patents Court permits fairly extensive disclosure for high-value disputes. Disclosure in FRAND trials centres on production of comparable licences, which is often extensive and contentious.  This places the UK toward the more invasive end of the spectrum compared with civil law systems, though still narrower than US-style discovery. FRAND/RAND disclosure is often narrower in scope but more commercially sensitive, since comparable licences are documents competitors would not otherwise have to exchange, which is why bespoke, multi-tier confidentiality clubs have become routine.

Transparency and precedent value

The UK is consistently ranked among the top jurisdictions globally for enforcement quality, judicial specialisation and the consistency and influence of decisions, which reinforces its precedential value both domestically and as a reference point for other common law courts. UK FRAND/RAND judgments are fully public (courts redact only true commercial secrets) and unusually detailed, extending to methodology (top-down cross-checks, comparable licences, willing-licensor/licensee analysis). They carry strong precedential weight domestically and are frequently cited by foreign courts, including the Chinese Supreme People’s Court in Sharp v Oppo. This reflects the open justice principle underlying all English commercial litigation, but FRAND/RAND cases push it further: courts have disclosed granular technical and commercial detail (such as component-level chip design information) beyond the confidentiality protections typical of general commercial claims, and beyond the “attorneys’ eyes only” practice standard in comparable US litigation.

Evidence Assessment/Cross-examination

A single specialist Patents Court judge (not a jury) tries FRAND/RAND trials following full disclosure, expert reports, and extensive cross-examination of economists and industry witnesses on royalty methodology and comparable licences. This produces detailed findings capable of surviving rigorous appellate scrutiny, as the multiple Court of Appeal and Supreme Court judgments upholding first-instance determinations show. What distinguishes FRAND trials is mainly scale and technical complexity, not the underlying evidentiary technique.